Skip to main content

Paul Davis

Full Service Water, Fire & Mold Cleanup + Restoration Specialists
Find Your Local Paul Davis

Are You Fully Prepared to Renew Your Homeowners Insurance Policy?

You just received a message from your insurance underwriter alerting that your homeowner policy renewal payment is soon due. ‘Darn, I meant to call my agent to shop around to see if I should update my coverage amounts and also see if there are more competitive rates available. Now. it’s probably too late.’ 

Not according to Brady Radmall, President, Paul Davis of Phoenix, AZ. “Being in the restoration business for years, we deal with hundreds of homeowners, many different insurance carriers and lots of independent agents and insurance underwriter in-house agents. Whether your home insurance agent is an independent, or bound to a specific provider, the right one will welcome your call to check coverages and to get you better insurance coverage at a good price. No matter which type of agent you have, your needs and your preferences are important to them.”

Hopefully you have an agent that you trust, one who has your best interests at heart, and one who really cares about your needs. If you already have such a person, meet with them every year or two to reassure you of their integrity. Don’t be shy. Ask probing questions about the companies they work for, how long they’ve represented them, and why they enjoy what they do. Ask them to tell you what they do to provide the best service; now as you’re renewing a policy and also what they’ve done in the past to help their customers maneuver claim reimbursements successfully. ‘Like what they say? Stick with them! Not so sure, shop around.’ 

Family, friends and neighbors will often suggest agents they partially like, and why. Note road signs and ads that you see and look some of these companies up, too. Take time to call first and then visit them if you like what they say. Homeowner policy coverages are complicated documents to read and understand. Different companies may offer different coverage or lower prices, but that’s not always the best choice. If company A offers lower coverage, you could end up paying more if you suffer damage and need to file a claim. If for example, company A sets replacement cost by an estimate and depreciates your property, versus actual replacement cost at claim time, that’s a big difference. Insurer B could use property information to determine how much it will actually cost to rebuild your home exactly as it was before being damaged. The coverages are therefore different. When one insurer comes in significantly lower than another, probe, ask why, and demand a full explanination.

Now, let’s get back to independent versus underwriter company agents. Since your independent agent quotes the policy with different insurers, you likely will have the same agent for as long as that person stays in business. Company employees, on the other hand, sometimes come and go. Over time, both agent types will get to know you and your family. However, the independent agent will have a wider array of companies from which he can give you a quote. They can be more sensitive to your family needs and more in sync with you, rather than the insurance company. This is good especially for homeowners in a rural area, with high claim activity, larger claims on the home, or bad credit. Those who are insurer company employees, can only quote within the guidelines of the insurer they work for and they may have to refer you elsewhere if a situation arises that you are declined policy renewal.

Using an insurance-direct agent can lead to multi-policy discount options by bundling home, car, liability coverage policies. This can save you money. But being locked in with one insurer may not be the best option for some people. This is especially true if you anticipate making changes to your home that would require changes in coverage. With an in-house insurance agent, you may be limiting your coverage options.

An independent home insurance agent can do the shopping for your policy. However, some independent agents will not handle the claim for you. They will refer you to your policy provider and employees of the provider will then be handling your claim; which means they may have more room to weigh in on your claim and be more helpful. Keep in mind that a provider’s employee still has loyalty to the provider. A company employee may provide better pricing. It all depends on the underwriting criteria of the provider for the product that you select and the rates for that particular carrier. Independents drop and pick up different insurance carriers all the time. They save you some time shopping by allowing you to get many quotes from different companies. 

If you need assigned-risk or high-risk liability coverage there are some in-house agents that can’t do this type of policy at all. The home insurance company that they are employed by may not sell these products. In this case, you may be referred to an independent agent who may have several options. Some companies only sell through company agents, or set lower rates if you purchase through them.

Confusing, isn’t it? Both agents set out to help you find the best discounts on your home insurance. This is true whether you’re buying homeowners insurance or a renters policy, one policy or several. Most insurance companies offer an array of policies from personal to business insurance. However, an independent may have a wider array to choose from because they have several companies available to them. Should anything go wrong or better rates occur, the independent agent can help you find a replacement homeowners insurance policy. “My advice,” Radmall concludes. “Do your homework early, ask the probing questions outlined here, be honest and forthright about your needs and concerns; and later, if you feel that your choice isn’t the best, repeat the process prior to the next renewal date, until you get a solid, long-term relationship with your agent.”

Tan USA Map with major cities of Paul Davis locations Tan USA Map with major cities of Paul Davis locations
FIND PAUL DAVIS NEAR YOU FIND PAUL DAVIS
NEAR YOU
With over 300 Paul Davis franchises in the United States and Canada, we are never far from you. Our impressive team of restoration specialists will handle returning your property and home back to their pre-damaged state.
From Coast To Coast, Paul Davis Has You Covered From Coast To Coast
Paul Davis Has You
Covered

Paul Davis Has You Covered

  • Address *
  • Street Address
  • Address Line 2
  • City
  • State / Province / Region
  • ZIP / Postal Code
  • Country
  • By clicking "Submit," you agree to our Terms of Use, which contains a mandatory arbitration provision.
Canadian Franchise Association Franchisees' Choice designation, 2018–2026
Canadian Franchise Association 2026 Awards of Excellence in Franchising, Gold, Non-Traditional
Entrepreneur Franchise 500, 2025
Entrepreneur Franchise 500, 2026
Franchise Times Top 400